huskilvr,
Some guys have good luck with only using sealant but I like to use a fiber gasket if possible. The condition of the two surfaces you are trying to seal are a big factor in that decision - usually the older the surfaces, the more chance of warpage and pitting and the need for a gasket.
Depending on your budget, you could consider using new replacement bolts and not mess around with the old bolts. You could also go with cadmium plated or even stainless steel bolts which would reduce or eliminate future corrosion. Some hardware stores may have them or you may have to order them in advance. As far as sealing, I've never had any problems as long as I got both sealing surfaces scraped clean of residual gasket material and any carbon & corrosion buildup.
I usually use some HI-TEMP sealer on gaskets where the surfaces have some pitting. Snug the bolts down evenly and then wait for a couple of hours or even over night before starting the engine to ensure you give the sealant a chance to cure.
Plan your work and work your plan - take your time and don't rush....
It works for me!
BarnieTrk
